The Phoenix Network:
Sign Up  |   About  |   Advertise
Features  |  Reviews

Review: 1911

Jackie Chan, deprived of his comic and physical skills, falls flat
By PETER KEOUGH  |  October 5, 2011
1.5 1.5 Stars

This year marks the centenary of the Xinhai Revolution, which ended the Qing Empire, established the first Chinese republic, and is celebrated by Chinese on both the mainland and Taiwan as the beginning of national independence. Few in the West know about it, and are likely to be more confused by this bombastic, incoherent, though occasionally eloquent period epic co-directed by Jackie Chan and Zhang Li. Chan, deprived of his comic and physical skills, falls flat as General Huang Xing, who glowers in the mud and blood of battlefields while the leader of the revolt, Sun Yat-Sen (Winston Chao), schmoozes with bankers and ministers in Europe. What it all means is not clarified much by the intertitles, such as one that explains how, upon further research, the body count in one incident has been revised from 72 to 86. Now and then, however, the joie de vivre of Chan's martial arts masterpieces emerges and brings the history to life.

Related: Review: Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, Review: Brighton Rock, Review: Machine Gun Preacher, More more >
  Topics: Reviews , China, Jackie Chan, War,  More more >
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 04/21 ]   Boston Comic Con  @ Hynes Convention Center
[ 04/21 ]   Death Cab for Cutie + Magik*Magik Orchestra + Low  @ Wang Theatre
[ 04/21 ]   Fun. + Miniature Tigers  @ House of Blues
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   REVIEW: A SIMPLE LIFE  |  April 18, 2012
    The most sensitive and heartbreaking depiction of old age since Korean director Lee Chang-dong's Poetry, Hong Kong filmmaker Ann Hui's aptly titled account of the slow decline of a beloved housekeeper doesn't involve violent crime like Lee's film, but does recreate the evanescence of everyday life with equal evocativeness.
  •   REVIEW: MARLEY  |  April 18, 2012
    After two-and-half hours of hagiography, talking heads, archival footage, still photos, and snatches of his songs, Bob Marley remains elusive in Kevin Macdonald's documentary.
  •   REVIEW: OK, GOOD  |  April 18, 2012
    Daniel Martinico's minimal, elliptical style and his use of repetitions and variations almost overcome the predictability of this case study in repression and alienation.
  •   REVIEW: SLEEPWALK WITH ME  |  April 18, 2012
    What compels people to perform comedy?
  •   REVIEW: KID-THING  |  April 18, 2012
    If Spirit of the Beehive took place in Napoleon Dynamite country, it might turn out like David Zellner's absurd and wrenching coming-of-age tale.

 See all articles by: PETER KEOUGH

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed